Mr. Richard Karkau, non-resident, representing the owner did not have a presentation.
Member Zinkin asked if the mechanical equipment would be screened.
The applicant responded the mechanical equipment will be located behind the parapet.
Member Zinkin asked if the windows would have some type of reflectivity. The applicant stated the windows are not reflective glass and will be tinted.
Bayer Vella, OV Principal Planner, presented the staff report and stated the design is on the contemporary edge. Mr. Vella presented photos of neighboring buildings and stated the design has been approved by the commercial association. Staff recommended approval with conditions in Exhibit A.
Member Zinkin asked if there was a code on the reflectivity of windows. Mr. Vella stated there is no specific code for window reflectivity.
Chairman Gribb asked if there were any discussions with the applicant to address the southwestern type of design. The applicant stated he was not approached about the design not fitting the code.
Member Caswell stated she believed the original Development Plan did not require southwest design in architecture.
MOTION: A motion was made by Member Shelton and seconded by Vice-Chair Caswell to approve OV13-08-09, The Architecture Company, representing the owner and applicant, requests approval of architectural elevations for lot 6 of Mercado Del Rio, with conditions in Exhibit A and add the reflectivity of the windows be discussed between the applicant and staff.
Member Zinkin stated he would vote against the motion because it does not meet design guidelines and has compatibility issues.
MOTION carried, 6-1 with Member Zinkin opposed
Paul Keesler, OV Development Review Manager, presented the proposal and reviewed the landscape plan.
Mr. Keesler stated staff recommended approval.
Member Zinkin asked if the landscape will be any degradation of safety. Mr. Keesler responded that part of OVZCR is to hide parking lots. This parking lot will be very well lit.
MOTION: A motion was made by Member Zinkin and seconded by Member Buette to approve OV12-08-17, The Town of Oro Valley Public Works Department, request approval of a landscape plan for a Oro Valley public transportation park and ride facility.
MOTION carried, 7-0
Karen Berchtold stated this action item is part of the steps needed to update code and address some new goals.
Member Zinkin suggested that Member Schoeppach be appointed and would be a great candidate.
Member Schoeppach is appointed by proclamation.
Member Zinkin stated he would request staff members who worked with the applicants be present at meetings.
Member Caswell stated it is unfair to come to a meeting and not have presentations in addition to staff reports.
Member Zinkin stated the bylaws read a presentation is a requirement.
Mr. Vella gave an update on upcoming Town Council and Study Sessions. Mr. Vella stated the Council is considering revising the appointment process of all boards and commissions and to eliminate the council liaison. This is currently being discussed and will be heard at the public meeting in January, if passed would take effect in July.
Mr. Gribb requested this item be put on the agenda to be discussed and possibly giving the Council a recommendation.
Mr. Vella continued and stated the proposed Art Review Code is going to be heard by the Town Council in December. The landscape code is still in process, considering water budgeting and a more restrictive plant palette.
MOTION: A motion was made by Member Schoeppach and seconded by Member Buette to adjourn at 7:06 p.m.